Skip to main content

Calibration: The Modern Approach to Reviews for Outstanding Performance

A shift is happening in the world of performance reviews. Gone are the days of rigid, one-size-fits-all performance reviews that often left both managers and employees scratching their heads. Instead, a more dynamic and effective approach has emerged: Performance Review Calibration. In this blog, we’ll explore the world of calibration, its two main types, and why it’s a game-changer for individuals, managers, and businesses.

Understanding calibration:

Breaking Down Talent and Performance

Before we dive in, let’s understand what calibration is. Calibration measures how well people are doing at work. It’s where managers, often from the same department or team, come together to discuss and align on employee performance evaluations. There are two main kinds:

Performance: Think of this as your work history book. It keeps track of all the milestones in your journey at work – from project successes to overcoming challenges, meeting deadlines, and being a team player. For example, let’s take Perry. She managed to deliver a tough project on time while working seamlessly with her team. That’s a prime example of a performance metric.

Talent: Talent is like peering into an employee’s future at the company. Instead of just noting what they’ve done, it gauges what they might achieve. It goes beyond what they’ve done so far and looks at their potential. This includes things like inherent abilities, how fast they learn, and their potential to take on more significant roles. Back to Perry, if she shows a knack for quickly understanding complex problems or mentoring junior team members, that’s her talent shining through.

Why Performance Calibration Matters

Now, you might be wondering, “Why does all this calibration stuff matter?” Well, without calibration, every manager could have their own interpretation of what counts as good or bad performance. For instance, one manager might see a high-achieving employee’s performance as merely “good,” while another might consider it outstanding. This can lead to some employees performing exceptionally but still receiving lower ratings than others.

This is where calibration swoops in to save the day. It helps managers agree on how to rate their team’s performance, ensuring that everyone’s experiences and viewpoints are considered. Over time, managers get a better understanding of the company’s perspective on performance, making feedback more objective and focused on the company’s goals. It’s not just one person’s opinion; it’s a collective insight from several leaders in the company.

The extra edge of talent calibration

Talent calibration takes things up a notch. Here, managers don’t just agree on performance ratings; they also discuss how to support and develop each employee further. This process helps identify who the standout performers are across the entire business. It’s like planning for the company’s future by spotting the next leaders or specialists early on.

An additional benefit is the chance to explore growth opportunities beyond one’s department. For instance, a talented individual might find opportunities to grow in another department where their skills can shine even more.

By putting people in roles that play to their strengths, they’re more motivated and engaged. This is great for the company because it not only makes the most of each person’s skills but also keeps them happy and loyal, reducing the chances they’ll leave.

The power of calibration in final assessments

Let’s take Elliot, an employee who excelled on a project and received high marks from his manager. But another manager pointed out that Elliot’s aggressive approach affected his colleagues negatively. Or, even more revealingly, Sadie from another team did most of the work while Elliot took the credit. This is where calibration shines. It offers multiple perspectives, ensuring that one’s performance is viewed in a more holistic manner, helping managers align on ratings.

The benefits of calibration are manifold:

  • Objective Alignment: Ensures that evaluations aren’t solely based on a single manager’s perspective.
  • Managerial Growth: Managers gain insights into their evaluation tendencies, helping them align with a broader business perspective over time.
  • Streamlined Process: As managers become more attuned to the calibration process, subsequent sessions become smoother and more efficient.

How calibration works

So, how does the calibration magic happen? Well, it’s a structured process that ensures a fair and unbiased evaluation:

  • Insight Gathering: A seasoned calibration facilitator kicks things off by gathering preliminary insights. This involves understanding managers’ independent ratings and collecting feedback from peers.
  • The Calibration Session: The heart of the process! This session is marked by open discussions, and the facilitator plays the role of the referee, making sure the conversations remain focused on objective calibration.
  • Visualisation: Visual aids like boards or images can provide clarity, helping attendees visualise ratings and make necessary adjustments in real-time.

How can you improve your calibration?

If you’re looking to up your calibration game, it starts with preparation. Managers should analyse their previous calibration rankings, identifying any biases or tendencies. During the session, being open and transparent about individual performance and sharing experiences with other managers’ reports ensures a well-rounded discussion.

Feedback should revolve around development for the upcoming year, giving managers the insights they need to guide their team members toward improvement. Plus, having an independent facilitator and visual aids, like ranking boards and individual images, can enhance objectivity and make the calibration process more insightful.

Common errors in the calibration process and how to avoid them

Calibration is a powerful tool, but it’s not without its pitfalls. Here are some common errors to watch out for:

  • Lack of Preparation: Ensure that facilitators and participants are well-prepared, with a clear understanding of individual ratings.
  • Overreliance on Manager’s Viewpoint: Don’t treat the manager’s perspective as absolute. Encourage input from all participants to maintain objectivity.
  • Focus on Development: Keep the discussion centred on what individuals need to develop in the upcoming year rather than on bonuses or salary adjustments.
  • Objective Facilitation: Avoid having individuals with strong opinions facilitate sessions, as this can influence outcomes.
  • Allocate Sufficient Time: Make sure there’s enough time for all individuals to be discussed thoroughly. This ensures fairness and accuracy in the calibration process.

Set Your Organisation on a Thriving Path with Calibration

In a nutshell, calibration is your secret weapon in the battle against traditional, bewildering performance reviews. If you’ve ever found yourself scratching your head, trying to make sense of it all, worry not! With MadeYou by your side, you’ll effortlessly sidestep the treacherous pitfalls of subjective ratings and inconsistent evaluations and be on your way to straightforward, fair, and objective performance assessments.

As you welcome performance calibration into your workplace, you’ll unlock a treasure trove of benefits. You’ll be aligning perspectives, nurturing talent, boosting employee engagement, and making savvy, well-informed decisions. Your organisation is set up to thrive like never before.

Fill out the form below, embrace calibration, and set forth on your journey to success.

Performance Review Calibration

Create an accurate and unbiased performance review process that makes employees strive to perform at their highest level.

360 Feedback

Empower individuals to embrace a feedback culture that promotes a company-wide growth mindset.
External Booking Form
CTA Forms